A Glimpse into India's Unique Identification System
In the vast landscape of digital governance, few initiatives have sparked as much debate as India's Aadhaar programme. Launched in 2009, this 12-digit unique identification number, tied to biometric and demographic data, was envisioned as a cornerstone for efficient service delivery. By April 2020, over 1.3 billion residents had enrolled, making it the world's largest biometric ID system. Yet, beneath its promise of transparency lies a complex reality marked by innovation, vulnerabilities, and ongoing controversies.
What is Aadhaar card in India? At its core, it is a proof of identity and residence, not citizenship, designed to streamline access to subsidies, banking, and welfare schemes. However, reports of data breaches and scams have raised alarms. A pivotal exposé in 2018 by The Tribune revealed how admin access to the Aadhaar database could be purchased for as little as Rs 500 via WhatsApp, granting outsiders the ability to query sensitive details like names, addresses, phone numbers, and even biometric data. This incident, verified by the newspaper through a controlled transaction, underscored the fragility of the system.
As of 1 April 2020, the Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI), the statutory body overseeing Aadhaar since 2016, had introduced enhancements like PVC cards with holograms for added security. Yet, questions persist: Is Aadhaar a beacon of progress or a ticking time bomb for privacy? This editorial explores the Aadhaar system in India neutrally, delving into its mechanics, risks, international dimensions, and implications for non-resident Indians (NRIs), Overseas Citizens of India (OCIs), and even US citizens with ties to India. We examine the reality of Aadhaar card through facts, historical context, and balanced analysis, incorporating insights up to early 2020.
What is Aadhaar Card in India? A Comprehensive Overview
To grasp the reality of Aadhaar card, one must first understand its foundational purpose. Aadhaar, meaning 'foundation' in Hindi, is not merely a card but a digital identity anchored in biometrics—fingerprints, iris scans, and facial photographs—linked to a resident's demographic details such as name, date of birth, gender, and address. Issued by UIDAI under the Aadhaar Act of 2016, it serves as a voluntary yet increasingly indispensable tool for authentication across sectors.
The Aadhaar programme traces its roots to 2009, when the government established UIDAI to address inefficiencies in welfare distribution. By April 2020, enrolment had reached 1.29 billion, covering 99% of India's adult population. Unlike traditional IDs like voter cards or passports, Aadhaar is probabilistic, relying on biometric matching rather than exact documents, which reduces duplication but introduces failure rates, especially in rural or arid regions where fingerprints degrade.
What is a Aadhaar card's role in daily life? It facilitates direct benefit transfers (DBT), linking subsidies for food, fuel, and pensions directly to bank accounts, potentially saving billions in leakages. In 2019-2020 alone, DBT disbursed over Rs 2.2 lakh crore through Aadhaar-enabled payments. Banks use it for e-KYC (electronic Know Your Customer), telecoms for SIM issuance, and even schools for admissions. However, the Supreme Court's 2018 verdict mandated its use only for subsidies and welfare, barring private entities like airlines from mandatory linkage—a partial safeguard against overreach.
For expatriates, the Aadhaar system extends beyond borders in intriguing ways. NRIs and OCIs often query: Aadhaar what is it for those abroad? It remains a resident-centric ID, but with provisions for overseas Indians. As we explore later, eligibility hinges on physical presence in India, making it a bridge for those maintaining ties.
Early Challenges: Authentication Hurdles and the Role of Village-Level Entrepreneurs
From inception, Aadhaar's biometric authentication faced practical obstacles. In Rajasthan, for instance, failure rates hovered around one-third due to worn fingerprints from manual labour or environmental factors. To mitigate this, UIDAI empowered Village-Level Entrepreneurs (VLEs)—local agents trained to conduct door-to-door verifications. These VLEs received admin access to the Central Identities Data Repository (CIDR), allowing them to update records and authenticate data on-site.
By 2020, over 1.5 lakh VLEs operated nationwide, bolstering enrolment in remote areas. This decentralised model enhanced accessibility but sowed seeds of vulnerability. Admin credentials, intended for legitimate use, became commodified. A VLE in Punjab, Bharat Bhushan Gupta, first flagged the issue in 2018 when he discovered WhatsApp groups hawking login IDs for Rs 500, enabling unrestricted database queries.
UIDAI's initial response was muted; complaints via helplines and emails went unanswered, prompting Gupta to approach the media. *The Tribune*'s investigation confirmed the breach: using purchased credentials, journalists accessed details of high-profile figures, including the Chief Justice of India. UIDAI dismissed it as 'not a hack' but a misuse of shared access, filing an FIR against the reporters—a move criticised for deflecting accountability.
Unpacking Aadhaar Scams: From Phishing to Identity Theft
The reality of Aadhaar card extends to its exploitation in frauds, with incidents multiplying by 2020. Phishing scams top the list: fraudsters, armed with leaked personal data, pose as bank officials. "Sir, to link your Aadhaar to your SBI account, share the OTP sent to your mobile," they coax. Victims, trusting the caller's knowledge of their name and number, comply—unwittingly granting access to withdraw funds.
A stark example unfolded in 2018 when a Rajya Sabha MP fell victim, losing thousands to such a ploy. By April 2020, UIDAI reported over 1,000 phishing complaints monthly, urging citizens never to share OTPs or biometrics over phone. Awareness campaigns emphasised in-person verification at branches.
More insidious was the 2017 Airtel e-KYC controversy. Customers visiting stores for SIM upgrades provided fingerprints for authentication. Unbeknownst, a second scan covertly opened zero-balance accounts under their name, diverting government subsidies like LPG cash transfers. Airtel, India's second-largest telco, enrolled millions this way without consent, prompting UIDAI to suspend its authentication licence temporarily. The ban lifted after compliance assurances, but it exposed systemic flaws in biometric consent.
SIM card frauds proliferated similarly. Enrolment agents, capturing fingerprints for one SIM, duplicated them for extras sold illicitly. A 2019 bust in Delhi uncovered 20,000 fake SIMs tied to stolen biometrics, potentially framing innocents in crimes—from cyber theft to terrorism probes.
Identity theft via Aadhaar peaked in pension scams. In 2019, Uttar Pradesh police arrested a gang siphoning Rs 40 lakh from elderly accounts by forging biometrics and linking fraudulent Aadhaars. Fake cards, printed with QR codes mimicking originals, flooded black markets, often used for Jan Dhan bank openings to launder funds.
These scams, while not unique to Aadhaar, amplify due to its centrality. By 2020, UIDAI's fraud detection algorithms flagged 5 lakh suspicious authentications daily, yet critics argued for stronger encryption and mandatory two-factor checks.
The Single Point of Failure: Why Aadhaar's Centralised Design Raises Alarms
Aadhaar's Achilles' heel is its monolithic database: one breach compromises everything—from bank links to mobile numbers. Pre-Aadhaar, Indians relied on siloed IDs: Voter ID for elections, PAN for taxes, passports for travel. Losing one didn't cascade; alternatives abounded.
Contrast this with the Aadhaar card USA equivalent, the Social Security Number (SSN). Often compared, yet distinct: SSN, a nine-digit identifier since 1936, primarily tracks earnings for retirement benefits. It's not biometric, lacks mandatory private-sector use, and enjoys robust privacy laws like the Privacy Act of 1974. Aadhaar, conversely, permeates 1,000+ services, from UPI payments to school admissions, heightening risks.
In the US, SSN misuse triggers credit freezes and alerts; India's Aadhaar lacks equivalent consumer protections. A 2019 CAG audit warned of 'vulnerabilities to frauds, fakes, and breaches,' citing unencrypted data transmissions in rural authentications. Fake Aadhaars surged, with 2018 reports of 10 crore ghost entries in welfare rolls.
From a scammer's lens, Aadhaar is a jackpot: hack once, plunder all. Voter ID hacks yield votes; Aadhaar unlocks fortunes. This centralisation, while efficient for DBT, invites corruption—ghost beneficiaries siphoning Rs 50,000 crore annually pre-Aadhaar.
Aadhaar for the Diaspora: Rules for NRIs, OCIs, and US Citizens
For millions of Indians abroad, the Aadhaar system poses unique queries: Can I get an Aadhaar card in USA? How to get Aadhaar card in USA? The answer, as of April 2020, is nuanced—enrolment demands physical presence in India.
NRIs (Indian citizens residing abroad) qualify if they've stayed 182+ days in the preceding 12 months. Process: Visit an Aadhaar Kendra (enrolment centre) with a valid passport. No online option exists; biometrics must be captured in-person. Minors require parental consent. Post-enrolment, the e-Aadhaar (digital version) arrives via email, while the physical PVC card (introduced 2020) mails later.
Aadhaar card India for NRI simplifies remittances and property dealings upon return. Yet, prolonged absence risks deactivation; UIDAI mandates address updates every decade.
For OCIs—foreign nationals of Indian origin—Aadhaar card for OCI eligibility mirrors NRIs but treats them as residents. Staying 182+ days with an Indian address allows enrolment, aiding visa renewals or investments. Getting Aadhaar card for OCI involves the same Kendra visit, passport as proof-of-identity, and proof-of-residence like a utility bill.
US citizens complicate matters. Aadhaar card for US citizens? Strictly, no—it's for Indian residents. Indians naturalising as US citizens must surrender passports, rendering them foreign nationals. What happens to Aadhaar card after US citizenship? UIDAI deactivates it upon notification, as eligibility lapses. A 2020 circular clarified: foreign citizenship voids Aadhaar, preventing misuse. Former holders can reapply as foreign residents if meeting stay criteria, but links to Indian services (e.g., PAN) sever.
Aadhaar Kendra USA? None exist; applications route through Indian consulates for guidance, but execution demands a India trip. Aadhaar card from USA involves planning: book via uidai.gov.in, carry originals. For dual intents, like estate inheritance, temporary re-enrolment post-renunciation is possible but bureaucratic.
This diaspora framework balances inclusion with residency focus, yet frustrates many. In 2019, over 50,000 NRIs enrolled upon visits, per UIDAI data.
Government Responses: Safeguards and Legal Evolutions by 2020
UIDAI's countermeasures evolved post-2018. Virtual IDs replaced numbers for authentications, masking exposure. By 2020, 90% of requests used this, reducing breach impacts. Facial authentication piloted for low-failure alternatives, while AI-driven anomaly detection curbed 99% of fraud attempts.
Legally, the 2018 Supreme Court ruling (Justice K.S. Puttaswamy vs Union of India) upheld Aadhaar's constitutionality but struck down mandatory private linkages, affirming privacy as fundamental. The 2016 Aadhaar Act criminalised unauthorised access with 3-10 year sentences.
Critics, including Edward Snowden, decried it as a 'tool for mass surveillance' in 2018 tweets, echoing 2014 concerns from then-opposition leader Narendra Modi about 'security threats'. By 2020, Modi’s administration touted Aadhaar's role in COVID-19 aid distribution, delivering Rs 500 crore to 25 crore women via DBT.
Yet, enforcement gaps lingered. A 2020 parliamentary panel flagged inadequate data localisation, with servers abroad risking foreign access.
Broader Implications: Privacy, Power, and Potential Misuse
Beyond scams, Aadhaar's 'kill switch' potential alarms. Deactivation—possible for inactivity or fraud—halts services. In 2019, 10 lakh numbers lapsed, stranding owners from rations amid lockdowns. Protests, like 2018 UP workers blocking a minister's cavalcade, saw sedition charges; hypothetically, Aadhaar suspension could amplify reprisals, freezing wages or benefits.
Comparatively, the Aadhaar system in India dwarfs global peers in scale but lags in safeguards. Estonia's e-ID, biometric-secured, mandates data minimisation; Aadhaar stores all centrally, vulnerable to quantum threats by 2030.
For US-India corridors, Aadhaar card USA queries spike among H-1B holders. Post-citizenship, Aadhar card US citizen status voids it, but legacy data persists unless deleted—a 2020 RTI revealed UIDAI retains records indefinitely for 'audit'.
Privacy advocates push for opt-outs; by 2020, 5 crore had masked biometrics. Yet, exclusion errors—5% rural failure rates—disenfranchise the marginalised.
Navigating the Aadhaar Landscape
The reality of Aadhaar card is neither utopian nor dystopian but a work-in-progress. It has revolutionised inclusion, curbing Rs 2.5 lakh crore in leakages since 2013, while exposing India to unprecedented risks. For NRIs eyeing Aadhaar card from USA or Aadhaar card for OCI, it's a practical tool if residency aligns—else, alternatives like passports suffice.
As of April 2020, UIDAI's upgrades signal commitment, but sustained vigilance—stronger laws, decentralised storage, diaspora-friendly reforms—is essential. Citizens must stay informed: verify calls, update details, and advocate. In a digital age, Aadhaar's true measure lies not in enrolment numbers but in trust earned.
Post a Comment